Founder article

Want to know if you can still be found and trusted?

Why ranking is no longer enough — and what a local business can control if it wants to be quoted by AI.

By Mark Wiltshire, Founder, S40 Works · July 2026

The short answer

AI answer tools no longer just list websites — they read them, then write one answer and quote a handful of sources. To be one of those quoted sources, your site has to be readable by AI, answer the question clearly in plain words, and prove it can be trusted. Ranking first on Google is no longer enough on its own.

What actually changed

For twenty years, search worked one way: you typed a question, Google gave you a list of blue links, and you clicked one. Your website’s job was to appear high on that list so people would click through to you.

That has changed. When you search now, an AI-written answer often sits above the list of links, and many people read it instead of clicking anything. Google’s AI Overviews grew from appearing in about 6.5% of searches in January 2025 to more than 50% by October 2025 (global). On searches where that AI answer appears, clicks through to websites have fallen sharply — by around 61% in one large study (global).

The shift in one sentence

Search engines used to send customers to your website; AI now reads your website and answers for the customer. If your site isn’t part of that answer, you’re invisible in a channel that is growing every month.

How AI chooses who to quote — the 30-second version

  • Step 1 — Find. The AI pulls a shortlist of pages from a search index. If your site isn’t indexed and readable, you’re out before the race starts. This is the old SEO game.

  • Step 2 — Choose. From that shortlist, the AI picks the pages that answer the question most clearly, specifically and credibly — and quotes them. This is the new game, and it’s where most small businesses lose.

This is why the common complaint — “I rank number one but the AI never mentions me” — happens. You can win Step 1 and still lose Step 2 because your answer is buried, vague or hard for a machine to read. Being in Google’s top ten no longer guarantees a mention: the overlap between top-ranked links and AI citations has dropped significantly since mid-2025 (global).

What AI rewards — in plain terms

  • A clear answer, first. Pages that open with a direct one- or two-sentence answer get quoted more readily than pages that make you scroll to find the point.

  • Real, specific facts. Named prices or ranges, response times, areas served and years in business. “We respond across the Southern Suburbs within 60 minutes” beats “world-class service” — a machine can quote a fact, not a slogan.

  • Clean structure. Proper headings, short paragraphs and behind-the-scenes labels (“schema”) that identify your name, address, phone, hours and services.

  • Trust signals. A named owner with a real bio, genuine reviews, real project photos and the same business details everywhere online.

  • Freshness. Content that shows a recent “last updated” date and gets refreshed, rather than launched once and forgotten.

The most important number for a local business

Roughly 58% of what AI “knows” about a local company comes from its own website, about 27% from third-party mentions and about 15% from directories (global). Your website is the single biggest lever you control.

What this means for a South African small business

Your customers are already using these tools. South Africa has about 50.8 million internet users — 78.9% of the population — and roughly 92% of internet traffic comes from a phone (South Africa). About 45% of South African adults use generative AI tools such as ChatGPT, the highest adoption on the continent (South Africa).

When a customer reaches for their phone and asks “best plumber near me” or “good family restaurant in Table View”, there is a growing chance an AI writes the shortlist — and only a few businesses make it onto that list. If your details are missing, unclear or inconsistent, you may not be one of them.

The opportunity: most small businesses have not adjusted yet. Very few are even tracking whether AI mentions them (global), leaving room for businesses that act first — which is exactly what Get Found is built to do.

What to do next

  • Check readability. Confirm your site is indexed, fast and not blocked to AI crawlers.

  • Answer first. Open every page with a direct answer in plain words.

  • Use quotable facts. Replace slogans with specific numbers and service details.

  • Remove inconsistency. Keep your name, address and phone identical across your website, Google and directories.

  • Stay current. Keep reviews active and content fresh.

Frequently asked questions

No. You still need to be found by search engines — that is Step 1. What has changed is that being found is no longer enough; you also need to be clear and credible enough to be quoted in the AI answer.

No, and be wary of anyone who promises it. AI selection shifts and differs between platforms. What you can do is stack every signal you control in your favour, improving your chances of being found, quoted and recommended.

Not always. Sometimes an existing site needs a focused set of fixes; sometimes its structure works against you and a rebuild is more efficient. A review tells you which.

›Show sources

Free Lost Opportunity Review

Want to know if AI can find and trust your business?

We’ll run your site through the signals above and show you, in plain language, where you’re losing customers before they reach you — and the fastest fixes to turn that around.

Alternative: hello@s40works.co.za